Bearing and speech — how a gentleman carries himself風操
1The bearing of the gentry — as mugwort grows in a hemp field
吾觀禮經,聖人之教:箕帚匕箸,咳唾唯諾,執燭沃盥,皆有節文,亦爲至矣。但旣殘缺,非復全書;其有所不載,及世事變改者,學達君子,自爲節度,相承行之,故世號士大夫風操。而家門頗有不同,所見互稱長短;然其阡陌,亦自可知。昔在江南,目能視而見之,耳能聽而聞之;蓬生麻中,不勞翰墨。汝曹生於戎馬之閑,視聽之所不曉,故聊記錄,以傳示子孫。
I have looked into the Li jing, and the teaching of the sages reaches even to the dustpan and the broom, the spoon and the chopsticks, coughing and spitting, the words of assent, the holding of the candle and the pouring of the washing water. All of it has its order and its form, and one may call it complete. Only it is already broken and missing and is no longer a whole book. What it does not carry, and what the affairs of the age have changed, gentlemen of thorough learning have set in order for themselves and handed on to one another, and so the world calls it the bearing of the gentry. Yet households differ a good deal, and each calls the other long or short according to what it has seen, though the main road can be known of itself. Long ago in Jiangnan my eyes could see it and my ears could hear it. Mugwort grows straight in a hemp field, and there was no need to trouble brush and ink. You were born among war horses, with nothing to learn by sight or hearing, and so I set this down roughly, to pass on and show to sons and grandsons.
2The man who wept at the words bitter cold (嚴寒) — how far a taboo name is carried
禮曰:「見似目瞿,聞名心瞿。」有所感觸,惻愴心眼;若在從容平常之地,幸須申其情耳。必不可避,亦當忍之;猶如伯叔兄弟,酷類先人,可得終身腸斷,與之絶耶?又:「臨文不諱,廟中不諱,君所無私諱。」益知聞名,須有消息,不必期於顛沛而走也。梁世謝舉,甚有聲譽,聞諱必哭,爲世所譏。又有臧逢世,臧嚴之子也,篤學修行,不墜門風;孝元經牧江州,遣往建昌督事,郡縣民庶,競修箋書,朝夕輻輳,幾案盈積,書有稱「嚴寒」者,必對之流涕,不省取記,多廢公事,物情怨駭,竟以不辦而還。此幷過事也。
The Li ji says, "See one who resembles him and the eye starts; hear the name and the heart starts." When something touches a man so that heart and eye grow sad, then in a quiet and ordinary place he may rightly let that feeling out. But where it cannot be avoided he must bear it. An uncle or a brother may look much like the one who is gone. Shall a man break his bowels for a lifetime and cut himself off from them? It says also, "In composing a text one does not taboo. Inside the ancestral shrine one does not taboo. Before the ruler there is no private taboo." From this it is the clearer that hearing a name calls for some measure, and that one need not hope to stumble away in flight. Xie Ju of Liang had a great name, yet whenever he heard his taboo name he would wail, and the world mocked him. There was also Zang Fengshi, the son of Zang Yan, deep in learning and careful in conduct, who did not let the bearing of his house fall. When Emperor Xiaoyuan governed Jiangzhou he sent him to Jianchang to oversee affairs. The people of the commanderies and counties vied in sending up letters, which crowded in morning and evening until they lay heaped on his desk. Whenever a letter had the words bitter cold (嚴寒) in it, he would face it and shed tears and not look it over or deal with it, so that much public business was left undone. People resented it and were shocked, and in the end he came back with nothing settled. Both of these went too far.
3A letter that gave the name and left out the surname
近在揚都,有一士人諱審,而與沈氏交結周厚,沈與其書,名而不姓,此非人情也。
Lately in Yangdu there was a scholar whose taboo name was Shen (審), and he was on close and warm terms with a man of the Shen (沈) family. When Shen sent him a letter he wrote his own personal name and not his surname. This is not what human feeling asks.
4In avoiding a taboo name, use a word of the same meaning
凡避諱者,皆須得其同訓以代換之:桓公名白,博有五皓之稱;厲王名長,琴有修短之目。不聞謂布帛爲布皓,呼腎腸爲腎修也。梁武小名阿練,子孫皆呼練爲絹;乃謂銷煉物爲銷絹物,恐乖其義。或有諱云者,呼紛紜爲紛煙;有諱桐者,呼梧桐樹爲白鐵樹,便似戲笑耳。
In every avoidance of a taboo name one must find a graph of the same meaning and put it in the other's place. Duke Huan's name was Bai (白), the white, and so the game board has the name five whites (五皓). King Li's name was Chang (長), the long, and so the zither has the name long and short (修短). But no one has heard cloth and silk (布帛) called bu hao (布皓), or the kidney and the bowel (腎腸) called shen xiu (腎修). Emperor Wu of Liang had the childhood name Alian (阿練), and his sons and grandsons all called lian (練), the raw silk, juan (絹). So they called the smelting and tempering of metal xiao juan (銷絹), which I fear runs against the sense. A man who tabooed yun (云) called fen yun (紛紜) fen yan (紛煙). A man who tabooed tong (桐) called the paulownia tree the white iron tree (白鐵樹). That is no better than a joke.
5The northern custom of naming a child donkey colt or piglet
周公名子曰禽,孔子名兒曰鯉,止在其身,自可無禁。至若衛侯、魏公子、楚太子,皆名蟣蝨;長卿名犬子,王修名狗子,上有連及,理未爲通,古之所行,今之所笑也。北土多有名兒爲驢駒、豚子者,使其自稱及兄弟所名,亦何忍哉?前漢有尹翁歸,後漢有鄭翁歸,梁家亦有孔翁歸,又有顧翁寵;晉代有許思妣、孟少孤:如此名字,幸當避之。
The Duke of Zhou named his son Qin (禽), the bird, and Confucius named his son Li (鯉), the carp. These stopped with the man himself, and so there was nothing to forbid. But the Marquis of Wey (衛), the Prince of Wei (魏) and the Crown Prince of Chu were all named Jishi (蟣蝨), nit and louse, and Changqing was named Quanzi (犬子), dog's son, and Wang Xiu was named Gouzi (狗子), puppy. These reach upward and touch the parents, and reason does not allow them. What the ancients did the present age laughs at. In the northern lands many name a child donkey colt or piglet. To make him call himself so, or to let his brothers name him so, how can a man bear it? The Former Han had Yin Wenggui, the Later Han had Zheng Wenggui, the house of Liang had Kong Wenggui and also Gu Wengchong, and the Jin age had Xu Sibi (許思妣) and Meng Shaogu (孟少孤). Such names ought rightly to be avoided.
6In naming a son, leave room for the grandson
今人避諱,更急於古。凡名子者,當爲孫地。吾親識中有諱襄、諱友、諱同、諱清、諱和、諱禹,交疏造次,一座百犯,聞者辛苦,無憀賴焉。
The men of today avoid taboo names more urgently than the ancients. Whoever names a son should leave ground for the grandson. Among my kin and acquaintance there are men who taboo Xiang (襄), You (友), Tong (同), Qing (清), He (和) and Yu (禹). Where the acquaintance is thin and the moment hurried, a hundred breaches are made at a single sitting, and those who hear it suffer and are at a loss.
7To take an ancient's surname into one's own name is a low thing
昔司馬長卿慕藺相如,故名相如,顧元嘆慕蔡邕,故名雍,而後漢有朱倀字孫卿,許暹字顔回,梁世有庾晏嬰、祖孫登,連古人姓爲名字,亦鄙事也。
Long ago Sima Changqing admired Lin Xiangru and so named himself Xiangru, and Gu Yuantan admired Cai Yong and so named himself Yong. But in the Later Han the courtesy name of Zhu Chang was Sunqing (孫卿) and the courtesy name of Xu Xian was Yan Hui (顔回), and in the age of Liang there were Yu Yanying (庾晏嬰) and Zu Sundeng (祖孫登). To carry an ancient's surname as well into one's name and courtesy name is a low thing.
8Liu Wenrao, who could not call a servant a beast
昔劉文饒不忍駡奴爲畜産,今世愚人遂以相戲,或有指名爲豚犢者:有識傍觀,猶欲掩耳,況當之者乎?
Long ago Liu Wenrao could not bring himself to scold a servant as livestock. The foolish men of this age have come to make sport of it with one another, and some point at a man's name and call him piglet or calf. A man of sense looking on from the side wants to stop his ears. How much more the one it falls upon?
9"Your Excellency must be Tao Zhugong's eldest son" — words traded in jest
近在議曹,共平章百官秩祿,有一顯貴,當世名臣,意嫌所議過厚。齊朝有一兩士族文學之人,謂此貴曰:「今日天下大同,須爲百代典式,豈得尙作關中舊意?明公定是陶朱公大兒耳!」彼此歡笑,不以爲嫌。
Lately in the Board of Deliberation, while the stipends of the hundred officers were being weighed together, one man of high rank, a noted minister of the age, thought what was proposed too generous. One or two men of the gentry and of letters in the court of Qi said to this noble, "Today the realm is made one, and this must serve as the model for a hundred generations. How can you still hold to the old mind of Guanzhong? Your Excellency must be Tao Zhugong's eldest son." They laughed together and took no offense.
10House father and house mother — how to speak of one's own elders
昔侯霸之子孫,稱其祖父曰家公;陳思王稱其父爲家父,母爲家母;潘尼稱其祖曰家祖:古人之所行,今人之所笑也。今南北風俗,言其祖及二親,無云家者;田裏猥人,方有此言耳。凡與人言,言己世父,以次第稱之,不云家者,以尊於父,不敢家也。凡言姑姊妹女子子:已嫁,則以夫氏稱之;在室,則以次第稱之。言禮成他族,不得云家也。子孫不得稱家者,輕略之也。蔡邕書集,呼其姑姊爲家姑家姊;班固書集,亦云家孫:今幷不行也。
Long ago the descendants of Hou Ba called their grandfather the house lord (家公). The Prince of Chensi called his father the house father (家父) and his mother the house mother (家母). Pan Ni called his grandfather the house grandfather (家祖). What the ancients did the men of today laugh at. In the customs of south and north today no one puts house (家) before grandfather or parents, and only coarse men of the fields and lanes speak so. In speaking with another of one's own father's elder brother, one names him by his order of birth and does not put house before it, because he stands above one's father and one dares not say house. In speaking of an aunt, an elder sister, a younger sister or a daughter, if she is already married one names her by her husband's surname, and if she is still at home one names her by her order of birth. The saying is that she has completed the rites into another clan and so cannot be called house. That sons and grandsons cannot be called house is because it makes light of them. In the collected letters of Cai Yong he calls his aunt and his elder sister the house aunt (家姑) and the house elder sister (家姊), and in the collected letters of Ban Gu there is also the house grandson (家孫). Today neither is used.
11Revered (尊) for another's elders, worthy (賢) for those below them
凡與人言,稱彼祖父母、世父母、父母及長姑,皆加尊字,自叔父母已下,則加賢字,尊卑之差也。王羲之書,稱彼之母與自稱己母同,不云尊字,今所非也。
In speaking with another, when one names his grandparents, his father's elder brother and that man's wife, his parents, or his elder aunt, one adds the word revered (尊) to all of them. From his father's younger brother and that man's wife downward one adds the word worthy (賢). This is the difference of high and low. In the letters of Wang Xizhi he names another man's mother as he names his own and does not add the word revered, and today this is held to be wrong.
12Condolence and the welcoming of guests, south and north
南人冬至歲首,不詣喪家;若不修書,則過節束帶以申慰。北人至歲之日,重行弔禮;禮無明文,則吾不取。南人賓至不迎,相見捧手而不揖,送客下席而已;北人迎送幷至門,相見則揖,皆古之道也,吾善其迎揖。
Men of the south do not go to a house in mourning at the winter solstice or at the new year. If they cannot send a letter, they put on their belt once the festival is past and go to give comfort. Men of the north hold the rite of condolence heavy on those very days. The rites have no clear text for it, and so I do not take it up. Men of the south do not go out to meet an arriving guest. On meeting they join their hands and do not bow, and in seeing a guest off they only step down from their mat. Men of the north both meet and see off as far as the gate, and on meeting they bow. Both are ways of the ancients, and I think well of the meeting and the bow.
13Calling oneself by one's own name is an old custom
昔者,王侯自稱孤、寡、不谷,自茲以降,雖孔子聖師,與門人言皆稱名也。後雖有臣僕之稱,行者蓋亦寡焉。江南輕重,各有謂號,具諸書儀;北人多稱名者,乃古之遺風,吾善其稱名焉。
Long ago kings and marquises called themselves the orphaned one (孤), the widowed one (寡) and the unworthy one (不穀). From that time downward, even Confucius, sagely teacher as he was, named himself by his own name in speaking with his disciples. Later there were the words servant (臣) and your servant (僕), but few used them. In Jiangnan the high and the low each have their forms of address, set out in the several books of letter forms (書儀). In the north many call themselves by their own name, which is what is left of the old custom, and I think well of that naming.
14Speaking of elders who are gone
言及先人,理當感慕,古者之所易,今人之所難。江南人事不獲已,須言閥閲,必以文翰,罕有面論者。北人無何便爾話説,及相訪問。如此之事,不可加於人也。人加諸己,則當避之。名位未高,如爲勛貴所逼,隱忍方便,速報取了;勿使煩重,感辱祖父。若沒,言須及者,則斂容肅坐,稱大門中,世父、叔父則稱從兄弟門中,兄弟則稱亡者子某門中,各以其尊卑輕重爲容色之節,皆變於常。若與君言,雖變於色,猶云亡祖亡伯亡叔也。吾見名士,亦有呼其亡兄弟爲兄子弟子門中者,亦未爲安貼也。北土風俗,都不行此。太山羊侃,梁初入南;吾近至鄴,其兄子肅訪侃委曲,吾答之云:「卿從門中在梁,如此如此。」肅曰:「是我親第七亡叔,非從也。」祖孝徵在坐,先知江南風俗,乃謂之云:「賢從弟門中,何故不解?」
When talk reaches those who have gone before, feeling and longing should rightly rise, and what was easy for the ancients is hard for the men of today. When men of Jiangnan cannot help speaking of their lineage they always do it in writing, and few discuss it face to face. Men of the north fall into such talk at any time and question one another about it. Such a thing must not be pressed upon another, and when another presses it upon oneself it should be turned aside. If a man's name and station are not high and one of rank and merit presses him, let him endure it and find a way to answer quickly and be done, and not let it grow long and heavy and bring shame on his grandfather and father. If they are gone and the words must reach them, let him compose his face and sit gravely and say the great gate (大門中). For a father's elder or younger brother he says the gate of the cousins, and for a brother he says the gate of so and so, the son of the one who is gone. In each case he makes the measure of his countenance from the high or low, the heavy or light of the matter, and all of it differs from the ordinary. In speaking with the ruler, though he changes his countenance, he still says my late grandfather (亡祖), my late elder uncle (亡伯), my late younger uncle (亡叔). I have seen even noted men call a dead brother the gate of his elder brother's son or of his younger brother's son, and this too does not sit well. The custom of the northern lands does not follow it at all. Yang Kan of Taishan went south in the early years of Liang. When I came to Ye lately, his elder brother's son Yang Su asked me in detail after Yang Kan, and I answered, "When your cousin's gate (從門中) was in Liang, it was thus and thus." Yang Su said, "He was my own seventh late uncle, not a cousin." Zu Xiaozheng was sitting there and knew the custom of Jiangnan already, and said to him, "Worthy gate of the younger cousin (賢從弟門中), how is it that you do not understand?"
15Bo and shu, brother's son and nephew — the words for kin
古人皆呼伯父叔父,而今世多單呼伯叔。從父兄弟姊妹已孤,而對其前,呼其母爲伯叔母,此不可避者也。兄弟之子已孤,與他人言,對孤者前,呼爲兄子弟子,頗爲不忍;北土人多呼爲姪。案:爾雅、喪服經、左傳,姪雖名通男女,幷是對姑之稱。晉世已來,始呼叔姪;今呼爲姪,於理爲勝也。
The ancients all said father's elder brother (伯父) and father's younger brother (叔父), while the present age commonly says only bo (伯) and shu (叔). When a cousin has already lost his father, to call his mother one's elder or younger aunt before his face cannot be avoided. When a brother's son has lost his father, to call him the son of one's elder brother or of one's younger brother before his face, in speaking with others, is hard to bear. Men of the northern lands commonly call him zhi (姪). Looking into the Erya, the Sangfu of the Yili and the Zuo zhuan, zhi is a word used of men and women alike, but always as a word said toward an aunt. From the Jin age men began to say uncle and zhi, and calling him zhi today is the better in reason.
16Jiangnan weeps at parting, the north parts laughing
別易會難,古人所重;江南餞送,下泣言離。有王子侯,梁武帝弟,出爲東郡,與武帝別,帝曰:「我年已老,與汝分張,甚以惻愴。」數行淚下。侯遂密云,赧然而出。坐此被責,飄颻舟渚,一百許日,卒不得去。北間風俗,不屑此事,歧路言離,歡笑分首。然人性自有少涕淚者,腸雖欲絶,目猶爛然;如此之人,不可強責。
Parting is easy and meeting is hard, and the ancients held this heavy. In Jiangnan, when they see a man off, they shed tears as they speak of the parting. A prince and marquis, a younger brother of Emperor Wu of Liang, was going out to an eastern commandery and took his leave. The emperor said, "I am old now, and parting from you grieves me deeply," and several lines of tears came down. The marquis then went out dry-eyed and red in the face. For this he was reproached, and he drifted about the riverbanks in his boat for a hundred days and more and in the end could not go. The custom of the north makes little of this. They speak of parting at the fork of the road and part laughing. Yet there are men whose nature holds few tears, and though their bowels are near breaking their eyes stay clear. Such men must not be reproached by force.
17Hebei, where the mother's parents are called house lord and house mother
凡親屬名稱,皆須粉墨,不可濫也。無風教者,其父已孤,呼外祖父母與祖父母同,使人爲其不喜聞也。雖質於面,皆當加外以別之;父母之世叔父,皆當加其次第以別之;父母之世叔母,皆當加其姓以別之;父母之群從世叔父母及從祖父母,皆當加其爵位若姓以別之。河北士人,皆呼外祖父母爲家公家母;江南田里間亦言之。以家代外,非吾所識。
The names for kin must all be set apart clearly and never mixed. A man without training, once his father is gone, calls his mother's parents by the same words as his father's parents, so that people do not like to hear him. Even in asking after them to their faces one should add outer (外) to set them apart. For a parent's elder and younger uncles one should add their order of birth to set them apart. For the wives of those uncles one should add their surname to set them apart. For a parent's several cousins of the uncle's line, and for a grandfather's brothers and their wives, one should add their office or their surname to set them apart. The gentlemen of Hebei all call the mother's parents house lord and house mother, and the country places of Jiangnan say it too. To put house in the place of outer is not something I know.
18"Flesh and bone grow distant easily, and I cannot bring myself to say clan"
凡宗親世數,有從父,有從祖,有族祖。江南風俗,自茲已往,高秩者,通呼爲尊,同昭穆者,雖百世猶稱兄弟;若對他人稱之,皆云族人。河北士人,雖三二十世,猶呼爲從伯從叔。梁武帝嘗問一中土人曰:「卿北人,何故不知有族?」答云:「骨肉易疏,不忍言族耳。」當時雖爲敏對,於禮未通。
In the generations of the clan there are the cousin's line (從父), the grandfather's line (從祖) and the clan line (族祖). By the custom of Jiangnan, beyond these, men of high office are all called revered, and those of the same ancestral order are called brothers though a hundred generations lie between. Speaking of them to another, they say clansman (族人). The gentlemen of Hebei still say cousin elder uncle and cousin younger uncle after twenty or thirty generations. Emperor Wu of Liang once asked a man of the central lands, "You are a man of the north. How is it that you do not know there is a clan?" He answered, "Flesh and bone grow distant easily, and I cannot bring myself to say clan." It was a quick answer at the time, but it does not hold in the rites.
19Is the elder a word to use of a woman?
吾嘗問周弘讓曰:「父母中外姊妹,何以稱之?」周曰:「亦呼爲丈人。」自古未見丈人之稱施於婦人也。吾親表所行,若父屬者,爲某姓姑;母屬者,爲某姓姨。中外丈人之婦,猥俗呼爲丈母,士大夫謂之王母、謝母云。而陸機集有與長沙顧母書,乃其從叔母也,今所不行。
I once asked Zhou Hongrang, "What does one call the sisters of one's father and mother, within the clan and without?" Zhou said, "They too are called the elder (丈人)." From of old I have not seen the word elder used of a woman. What my own kin do is this. On the father's side she is the aunt of such and such a surname, and on the mother's side she is the mother's sister of such and such a surname. The wife of an elder within the clan or without is coarsely called the elder mother (丈母), while gentlemen say Mother Wang (王母) or Mother Xie (謝母). In the collected works of Lu Ji there is a letter to Mother Gu of Changsha, who was the wife of his father's cousin. This is not done today.
20Vice Director Zu, whom the gentlemen of Qi called Zu gong
齊朝士子,皆呼祖僕射爲祖公,全不嫌有所涉也,乃有對面以相戲者。
The gentlemen of the court of Qi all called Vice Director Zu by the name Zu gong (祖公), and did not mind at all that it ran into the word for an ancestor. There were even those who made sport of it to his face.
21The name is tabooed, the courtesy name is spoken
古者,名以正體,字以表德,名終則諱之,字乃可以爲孫氏。孔子弟子記事者,皆稱仲尼;呂后微時,嘗字高祖爲季;至漢爰種,字其叔父曰絲;王丹與侯霸子語,字霸爲君房;江南至今不諱字也。河北士人全不辨之,名亦呼爲字,字固呼爲字。尙書王元景兄弟,皆號名人,其父名雲,字羅漢,一皆諱之,其餘不足怪也。
In old times the name set the body straight and the courtesy name showed the virtue. When a man died his name was tabooed, while his courtesy name could be taken as a grandson's clan name. The disciples of Confucius who set down his affairs all called him Zhongni. Empress Lü, while she was still of low estate, called Gaozu by his courtesy name Ji. Yuan Zhong of Han called his uncle by his courtesy name Si. Wang Dan, speaking with the son of Hou Ba, called Hou Ba by his courtesy name Junfang. Jiangnan does not taboo the courtesy name even now. The gentlemen of Hebei cannot tell them apart at all. They call the name a courtesy name, and the courtesy name they of course call a courtesy name. Director Wang Yuanjing and his brothers were all men of note. Their father's name was Yun (雲) and his courtesy name Luohan (羅漢), and they tabooed them both. The rest, then, is no wonder.
22There are words in weeping too
禮閑傳云:「斬縗之哭,若往而不反;齊縗之哭,若往而反;大功之哭,三曲而偯;小功緦麻,哀容可也,此哀之發於聲音也。」孝經云:「哭不偯。」皆論哭有輕重質文之聲也。禮以哭有言者爲號;然則哭亦有辭也。江南喪哭,時有哀訴之言耳;山東重喪,則唯呼蒼天,期功以下,則唯呼痛深,便是號而不哭。
The Jianzhuan of the Li ji says, "The weeping of the deepest mourning goes out and does not come back. The weeping of the next degree goes out and comes back. The weeping of the great degree bends three times and trails away. For the small degree and the hempen degree a grieving face is enough. This is grief coming out as sound." The Xiao jing says, "In weeping one does not trail the voice." All of this speaks of weeping as having sounds that are light or heavy, plain or shaped. The rites call weeping that has words in it a calling out (號). If so, then weeping too has its words. The mourning cry of Jiangnan has at times words of sorrowful appeal. In Shandong, in heavy mourning, they cry out only "blue heaven," and below the year's degree and the great degree they cry out only "the pain is deep." That is a calling out and not a weeping.
23If no condolence comes within three days, the tie is cut
江南凡遭重喪,若相知者,同在城邑,三日不弔則絶之;除喪,雖相遇則避之,怨其不己憫也。有故及道遙者,致書可也;無書亦如之。北俗則不爾。江南凡弔者,主人之外,不識者不執手;識輕服而不識主人,則不於會所而弔,他日修名詣其家。
In Jiangnan, when a man meets a heavy mourning, an acquaintance living in the same walled town who does not come to condole within three days is cut off. Even after the mourning is put away, if they meet he is avoided, out of resentment that he did not pity the grief. If a man had reason to stay away, or the road was far, a letter will do, and if there is no letter it is judged the same. The custom of the north is not so. In Jiangnan, when men condole, they take no one by the hand but the chief mourner unless they know him. If a man knows one in light mourning but not the chief mourner, he does not condole at the gathering, but writes out his name on another day and goes to the house.
24The saying that one must not weep on a chen day
陰陽説云:「辰爲水墓,又爲土墓,故不得哭。」王充論衡云:「辰日不哭,哭則重喪。」今無教者,辰日有喪,不問輕重,舉家清謐,不敢發聲,以辭弔客。道書又曰:「晦歌朔哭,皆當有罪,天奪其算。」喪家朔望,哀感彌深,寧當惜壽,又不哭也?亦不諭。
The teaching of yin and yang says, "Chen (辰) is the tomb of water and also the tomb of earth, and so one must not weep." The Lun heng of Wang Chong says, "On a chen day one does not weep, for weeping brings mourning upon mourning." Untaught men today, when a death falls on a chen day, ask nothing of light or heavy, but keep the whole house still, dare not raise a sound, and turn away those who come to condole. The Daoist books say also, "To sing on the last day of the moon and to weep on the first brings guilt, and heaven takes away the years of one's life." In a house of mourning grief runs deeper on the first day and the fifteenth. Shall a man grudge his years and not weep then either? This too is past understanding.
25Sons and grandsons who flee the returning spirit (歸殺)
偏傍之書,死有歸殺。子孫逃竄,莫肯在家;畫瓦書符,作諸厭勝;喪出之日,門前然火,戶外列灰,祓送家鬼,章斷注連:凡如此比,不近有情,乃儒雅之罪人,彈議所當加也。
The books of the side arts say that the dead have a returning spirit (歸殺). Sons and grandsons run off and hide, and none will stay in the house. They paint on tiles and write charms and make all sorts of spells (厭勝). On the day the bier goes out they light a fire before the gate and lay ashes outside the door, washing away the house ghost and cutting the binding cord (注連) with a charm. All such things are far from human feeling. These are offenders against learning and refinement, and impeachment should fall upon them.
26To weep while bowing at a festival is human feeling
己孤,而履歲及長至之節,無父,拜母、祖父母、世叔父母、姑、兄、姊,則皆泣;無母,拜父、外祖父母、舅、姨、兄、姊,亦如之:此人情也。
When a man has lost his father, and the new year or the winter solstice comes, and with no father he bows to his mother, his grandparents, his uncles and their wives, his aunt, his elder brother and his elder sister, he weeps at every one of them. When he has no mother and bows to his father, his mother's parents, his mother's brother, his mother's sister, his elder brother and his elder sister, it is the same. This is human feeling.
27"Pei Zhili is not dead"
江左朝臣,子孫初釋服,朝見二宮,皆當泣涕;二宮爲之改容。頗有膚色充澤,無哀感者,梁武薄其爲人,多被抑退。裴政出服,問訊武帝,貶瘦枯槁,涕泗滂沱,武帝目送之曰:「裴之禮不死也。」
Among the court officials of Jiangzuo, when a son or grandson first put off mourning dress and appeared before the two palaces, he was to shed tears, and the two palaces changed countenance for him. Now and then one came with his flesh full and glossy and no look of grief, and Emperor Wu of Liang thought little of such a man and often held him back and put him aside. When Pei Zheng put off mourning and came to greet Emperor Wu, he was thin and worn, and tears and mucus ran down in streams. The emperor followed him with his eyes and said, "Pei Zhili is not dead."
28The room a parent lived in, and the thing that brought a parent's death
二親旣沒,所居齋寢,子與婦弗忍入焉。北朝頓丘李構,母劉氏,夫人亡後,所住之堂,終身鎖閉,弗忍開入也。夫人,宋廣州刺史纂之孫女,故構猶染江南風教。其父奬,爲揚州刺史,鎮壽春,遇害。構嘗與王松年、祖孝徵數人同集談燕。孝徵善畫,遇有紙筆,圖寫爲人。頃之,因割鹿尾,戲截畫人以示構,而無他意。構愴然動色,便起就馬而去。舉坐驚駭,莫測其情。祖君尋悟,方深反側,當時罕有能感此者。吳郡陸襄,父閑被刑,襄終身布衣蔬飯,雖薑菜有切割,皆不忍食;居家惟以掐摘供廚。江寧姚子篤,母以燒死,終身不忍噉炙。豫章熊康父以醉而爲奴所殺,終身不復嘗酒。然禮緣人情,恩由義斷,親以噎死,亦當不可絶食也。
When both parents are gone, the study and the sleeping room where they lived are rooms a son and his wife cannot bear to enter. In the Northern Court, Li Gou of Dunqiu, after his mother of the Liu family died, kept the hall where she had lived locked for the rest of his life and could not bear to open it and go in. The lady was the granddaughter of Liu Zuan, Inspector of Guangzhou under Song, and so Li Gou was still steeped in the training of Jiangnan. His father Li Jiang was Inspector of Yangzhou and was killed while holding Shouchun. Li Gou once sat drinking and talking with Wang Songnian, Zu Xiaozheng and a few others. Zu Xiaozheng was good at painting, and whenever paper and brush came to hand he drew people. Presently, while cutting a deer's tail, he cut through the painted figure in play and showed it to Li Gou, meaning nothing by it. Li Gou grew sad, his face changed, and he rose at once, took his horse and went. The whole company was startled and could not fathom his heart. Zu soon understood and only then grew deeply uneasy, and few at that time could feel such a thing. Lu Xiang of Wu commandery, whose father Lu Xian was put to death by sentence, wore hemp and ate vegetable food all his life, and could not bear to eat even ginger or greens that had been cut with a knife, so that at home they plucked things by hand for the kitchen. Yao Zidu of Jiangning, whose mother burned to death, could not bear to eat roasted food all his life. Xiong Kang of Yuzhang, whose father was killed by a servant while drunk, never tasted wine again. Yet the rites follow human feeling, and kindness is cut off by right measure. If a parent choked to death, one still cannot give up eating.
29The books a father left, the cup a mother used
禮經:父之遺書,母之杯圈,感其手口之澤,不忍讀用。政爲常所講習,讎校繕寫,及偏加服用,有迹可思者耳。若尋常墳典,爲生什物,安可悉廢之乎?旣不讀用,無容散逸,惟當緘保,以畱後世耳。
The Li jing says that the books a father left and the cup a mother used carry the trace of their hands and mouths, so that one cannot bear to read them or use them. That was said of what they always studied and recited, collated and copied out, and of what they used more than other things, where a trace remains that can be longed for. As for ordinary books and the goods of daily life, how can all of them be set aside? Though they are not read or used, they must not be let go and scattered. They should only be sealed and kept, and left to later ages.
30The daughter whose bowels broke at the sight of her mother's screen
思魯等第四舅母,親吳郡張建女也,有第五妹,三歲喪母。靈牀上屛風,平生舊物,屋漏沾濕,出曝曬之,女子一見,伏牀流涕。家人怪其不起,乃往抱持;薦席淹漬,精神傷怛,不能飲食。將以問醫,醫診脈云:「腸斷矣!」因爾便吐血,數日而亡。中外憐之,莫不悲嘆。
The fourth aunt by marriage of Siru and his brothers was a daughter of Zhang Jian of Wu commandery. She had a fifth younger sister who lost her mother at three. The screen above the spirit couch (靈牀) was a thing the mother had used all her life, and when the roof leaked and it grew damp they brought it out to dry in the sun. The girl saw it once and fell upon the couch weeping. The household thought it strange that she did not get up and went to take her in their arms. The mat was soaked through, her spirit was wounded, and she could not eat or drink. They asked a physician, who felt her pulse and said, "The bowels are broken." From then she vomited blood, and within a few days she died. Kin within and without pitied her, and none but grieved and sighed.
31What it means not to take pleasure on the day of a death
禮云:「忌日不樂。」正以感慕罔極,惻愴無聊,故不接外賓,不理眾務耳。必能悲慘自居,何限於深藏也?世人或端坐奧室,不妨言笑,盛營甘美,厚供齋食;迫有急卒,密戚至交,盡無相見之理:蓋不知禮意乎!
The Li ji says, "On the day of a parent's death one does not take pleasure." It is only that longing has no bound and grief leaves the heart nowhere to rest, and so one does not receive guests from outside and does not handle the many affairs. If a man can truly dwell in his sorrow, why should it be a matter of hiding deep within? Some men of the world sit upright in an inner room and do not mind laughing and talking. They set out rich and sweet things and serve the fast-day meal (齋食) generously, and yet, though some sudden and urgent matter comes, close kin and dearest friends have no way at all to see them. This is not knowing what the rites mean.
32When a mother dies on the day of the earth god
魏世王修母以社日亡;來歲社日,修感念哀甚,鄰里聞之,爲之罷社。今二親喪亡,偶値伏臘分至之節,及月小晦後,忌之外,所經此日,猶應感慕,異於餘辰,不預飲燕、聞聲樂及行遊也。
In the age of Wei the mother of Wang Xiu died on the day of the earth god (社日). When that day came round the next year, Wang Xiu grieved so deeply in his longing that the neighbors heard of it and gave up the sacrifice for his sake. Today, if the day a parent died happens to fall on one of the festivals, the dog days, the winter sacrifice, the equinoxes or the solstices, or after the last day of a short month, then besides the day of death itself one should still feel longing when such a day passes. It is to be kept apart from other days, and one does not join in feasting, or listen to music, or go out roaming.
33One cannot avoid every different graph that sounds the same
劉縧、緩、綏,兄弟幷爲名器,其父名昭,一生不爲照字,惟依爾雅火旁作召耳。然凡文與正諱相犯,當自可避;其有同音異字,不可悉然。劉字之下,即有昭音。呂尙之兒,如不爲上;趙壹之子,儻不作一:便是下筆即妨,是書皆觸也。
Liu Tao, Liu Huan and Liu Sui were brothers, and all of them men of standing. Their father's name was Zhao (昭), and all their lives they would not write the graph zhao (照), but followed the Erya and wrote the fire radical (火) beside zhao (召). Yet when a text strikes the taboo name itself it can rightly be avoided, while graphs that merely share the sound cannot all be treated so. Beneath the graph Liu (劉) there lies the sound zhao. If the son of Lü Shang would not write shang (上), and the son of Zhao Yi would not write yi (一), then the brush would catch as soon as it was lifted, and every piece of writing would strike something.
34"When will your revered father call at the house?"
嘗有甲設燕席,請乙爲賓;而旦於公庭見乙之子,問之曰:「尊侯早晚顧宅?」乙子稱其父已往。時以爲笑。如此比例,觸類愼之,不可陷於輕脫。
Once a man called Jia set out a feast and asked a man called Yi to be his guest. In the morning he saw Yi's son in the public court and asked him, "When will your revered father (尊侯) call at the house?" Yi's son answered that his father had already gone. It was a laughingstock at the time. In such cases one must take care in every like matter and not fall into loose speech.
35The first-year grasping — testing the child (試兒)
江南風俗,兒生一期,爲製新衣,盥浴裝飾,男則用弓矢紙筆,女則刀尺針縷,幷加飲食之物,及珍寶服玩,置之兒前,觀其發意所取,以驗貪廉愚智,名之爲試兒。親表聚集,致燕享焉。自茲已後,二親若在,每至此日,嘗有酒食之事耳。無教之徒,雖已孤露,其日皆爲供頓,酣暢聲樂,不知有所感傷。梁孝元年少之時,每八月六日載誕之辰,常設齋講;自阮修容薨歿之後,此事亦絶。
By the custom of Jiangnan, when a child has lived a full year they make new clothes for it, wash and dress it, and set before it a bow and arrows, paper and brush for a boy, or a knife, a measure, a needle and thread for a girl, along with things to eat, treasures, clothes and playthings. They watch which it reaches for as its mind moves, and read from it greed or restraint, dullness or wit. This is called testing the child (試兒). Kin gather and a feast is held. From that day on, while both parents live, there is a setting out of wine and food whenever the day comes round. Untaught men, though their parents are already gone, still lay out the feast on that day and drink deep to music, not knowing there is anything to grieve. Emperor Xiaoyuan of Liang, when he was young, always held a fast and a lecture on the sixth day of the eighth moon, the day of his birth. After the Lady Ruan Xiurong died, this too came to an end.
36The cry a man makes in pain
人有憂疾,則呼天地父母,自古而然。今世諱避,觸途急切。而江東士庶,痛則稱禰。禰是父之廟號,父在無容稱廟,父歿何容輒呼?蒼頡篇有侑字,訓詁云:「痛而謼也,音羽罪反。」今北人痛則呼之。聲類音於耒反,今南人痛或呼之。此二音隨其鄉俗,幷可行也。
When a man is troubled or in pain he calls on heaven and earth and on his father and mother, and it has been so from of old. The present age taboos and avoids, and presses it hard at every turn. Yet the gentlemen and the common folk of Jiangdong, when they are in pain, cry ni (禰). Ni is the shrine name of a father. While a father lives his shrine name cannot be spoken, and once he is gone how can it be called out lightly? The Cangjie pian has the graph you (侑), and the gloss says, "It is a cry made in pain, sounded as the initial of yu (羽) with the final of zui (罪)." Men of the north cry this today when they are in pain. The Sheng lei gives the sound as the initial of yu (於) with the final of lei (耒), and men of the south sometimes cry this today when they are in pain. These two sounds follow the custom of the place, and both may be used.
37When a father is imprisoned, his sons go barefoot to the palace gate
梁世被繫劾者,子孫弟姪,皆詣闕三日,露跣陳謝;子孫有官,自陳解職。子則草屩麤衣,蓬頭垢面,周章道路,要候執事,叩頭流血,申訴冤枉。若配徒隸,諸子幷立草庵於所署門,不敢寧宅,動經旬日,官司驅遣,然後始退。江南諸憲司彈人事,事雖不重,而以教義見辱者,或被輕繫而身死獄戶者,皆爲怨讎,子孫三世不交通矣。到洽爲御史中丞,初欲彈劉孝綽,其兄漑先與劉善,苦諫不得,乃詣劉涕泣告別而去。
In the age of Liang, when a man was bound and impeached, his sons and grandsons, his younger brothers and his nephews all went to the palace gate for three days and made apology bare-headed and barefoot, and any of them holding office asked to be relieved of it. The son wore straw sandals and coarse clothes, his hair loose and his face soiled, and wandered the roads waiting for the officers in charge, knocking his head until blood ran and pleading the wrong done. If the man was sent to hard labor (徒隸), the sons all raised a straw hut before the gate of the office and dared not rest at home. Often ten days passed, and only when the officers drove them off did they withdraw. When the censorial offices (憲司) of Jiangnan impeached a man, even in a light matter, if he was shamed in the name of teaching and right, or if he was lightly bound and died in the prison house, they became enemies, and their sons and grandsons did not visit one another for three generations. When Dao Qia became Palace Aide to the Censor-in-Chief and first meant to impeach Liu Xiaochuo, his elder brother Dao Gai, who had long been close to Liu, pleaded hard with him and could not move him. So he went to Liu, wept, said farewell and left.
38When a father is with the army
兵兇戰危,非安全之道。古者,天子喪服以臨師,將軍鑿兇門而出。父祖伯叔,若在軍陣,貶損自居,不宜奏樂燕會及婚冠吉慶事也。若居圍城之中,憔悴容色,除去飾玩,常爲臨深履薄之狀焉。父母疾篤,醫雖賤雖少,則涕泣而拜之,以求哀也。梁孝元在江州,嘗有不豫;世子方等親拜中兵參軍李猷焉。
Arms are ill-omened and battle is perilous, and this is no path of safety. In old times the Son of Heaven put on mourning dress to go before the army, and the general broke through the gate of ill omen (兇門) as he went out. If a father, a grandfather or an uncle is with the army, a man lowers himself in how he lives, and should not hold music or feasts, or weddings, cappings and other happy occasions. If he is inside a besieged city he wears a worn face and puts away ornaments and playthings, keeping always the look of one who stands at deep water or treads on thin ice. When a parent is gravely ill, then though the physician be low in station and young in years, one weeps and bows to him to ask his pity. When Emperor Xiaoyuan of Liang was in Jiangzhou he once fell ill, and the heir Fangdeng bowed in person to Li You, Adjutant of the Central Troops.
39Men of the north who swear brotherhood at a meeting on the road
四海之人,結爲兄弟,亦何容易。必有志均義敵,令終如始者,方可議之。一爾之後,命子拜伏,呼爲丈人,申父友之敬;身事彼親,亦宜加禮。比見北人,甚輕此節,行路相逢,便定昆季,望年觀貌,不擇是非,至有結父爲兄,託子爲弟者。
For men of the four seas to bind themselves as brothers, how can that be easy? Only with one whose purpose is level with one's own and whose sense of right is a match, one who will end as he began, can the matter be discussed. Once it is bound, a man bids his son bow low and call the other the elder (丈人), showing the respect owed to a father's friend, and he should himself serve that man's parents with added rite. Lately I see that men of the north hold this step very lightly. They meet on the road and settle at once which is the elder brother and which the younger. They look at the years and look at the face and do not sift right from wrong. There are even those who bind a man of a father's years as an elder brother, or take one of a son's years as a younger brother.
40A guest is not left standing at the gate
昔者,周公一沐三握發,一飯三吐餐,以接白屋之士,一日所見者七十餘人。晉文公以沐辭竪頭須,致有圖反之誚。門不停賓,古所貴也。失教之家,閽寺無禮,或以主君寢食嗔怒,拒客未通,江南深以爲恥。黃門侍郎裴之禮,號善爲士大夫,有如此輩,對賓杖之;其門生僮僕,接於他人,折旋俯仰,辭色應對,莫不肅敬,與主無別也。
Long ago the Duke of Zhou gripped his wet hair three times at a single washing and spat out his food three times at a single meal, so as to receive the scholars of thatched houses, and in one day he saw more than seventy men. Duke Wen of Jin put off Toushu on the excuse of washing his hair, and drew on himself the reproach that his mind had turned about. Not to leave a guest standing at the gate is what the ancients prized. In a house that has lost its training the gatekeeper is without manners, and sometimes he turns a guest away and does not announce him, saying the master is asleep, or eating, or angry. In Jiangnan this is held a deep shame. Pei Zhili, Gentleman Attendant at the Yellow Gates, was said to play the gentleman well, and when he had such men about him he had them beaten in front of the guest. His retainers and servants, in dealing with others, turned and bowed and answered in word and countenance with nothing but gravity and respect, and were no different from their master.