Yetgeul › Ming Shi Chaoxian Zhuan (Account of Joseon in the History of Ming) › Complete in one volume

Joseon 6 — Jong, King Injo, and the end of the Ming朝鮮 六

Ming Shi Chaoxian Zhuan (Account of Joseon in the History of Ming) 明史 朝鮮傳 · Zhang Tingyu and others · 1739 (Qing, 4th year of the Qianlong era) · 13 passages · 2,068 Chinese characters · reading time 8.3 min

Ming Shi Chaoxian Zhuan (Account of Joseon in the History of Ming) Complete in one volume Three hundred years of Joseon as the Ming saw them. Here are the turning back of the army at Wihwado and the choosing of the name Joseon; the two-hundred-year struggle over the false record of the royal lineage; and, filling half the account, the whole course of the seven years of the Imjin War — Pyongyang, Byeokjegwan, Ulsan, Noryang. It is the last account of Joseon in a standard history, and it closes: "It was called a vassal state, yet it was no different from within the borders."

1The restoration of Injo and the debate on investiture

三年四月,國人廢琿而立其姪綾陽君倧,以昭敬王妃之命權國事,令議政府移文督撫轉奏,文龍為之揭報。登州巡撫袁可立上言:「琿果不道,宜聽太妃具奏,以待中國更立。」疏留中。八月,王妃金氏疏請封倧,禮部尚書林堯俞言:「朝鮮廢立之事,內外諸臣抒忠發憤,有謂宜聲罪致討者,有謂勿遽討且受方貢覈顛末者,或謂當責以大義,察輿情之向背者,或謂當令倧討敵自洗者,眾論咸有可采。其謂琿實悖德,倧討叛臣以赤心奉朝廷者,惟文龍一人耳。皇上奉天討逆,扶植綱常,此正法也。毋亦念彼素稱恭順,迥異諸裔,則更遣貞士信臣,會同文龍,公集臣民,再四詢訪。勘辨既明,再請聖斷。」報可。十二月,禮部復上言:「臣前同兵部移咨登撫,幷劄毛帥,遣官往勘。今據申送彼國公結十二道,自宗室至八道臣民共稱倧為恭順。且彼之陪臣相率哀籲,謂當此危急之秋,必須君國之主。乞先頒敕諭,令倧統理國事,仍令發兵索賦,同文龍設伏出奇,俟漸有次第,始遣重臣往正封典。庶幾字小之中,不失固圉之道。」從之。四年四月,封倧為國王。

In the fourth month of the third year the people of the country deposed Hon and set up his nephew Jong (倧), prince of Neungyang, who took charge of the affairs of state by the command of the queen of King Sogyeong. The State Council sent a dispatch to the supreme commander and the governor to report it on their behalf, and Wenlong sent a notice of it as well. Yuan Keli, governor of Denglai, said, "If Hon is truly without principle, the queen dowager should be allowed to set it out in full and wait for China to set up another." The memorial was kept in the palace. In the eighth month Queen Kim memorialized asking that Jong be invested, and Lin Yaoyu, minister of Rites, said: "On this deposing and setting up in Joseon, the ministers within and without have poured out their loyalty and their indignation. Some say his guilt should be proclaimed and a punitive force sent. Some say we should not be hasty to punish, but for the time being receive the tribute and look into how it came about. Some say he should be called to account by the great principle and the leaning of the people's feeling observed. Some say Jong should be told to strike the enemy and wash himself clean. In all these views there is something to be taken. But the only one who says that Hon truly went against virtue and that Jong struck down a rebellious subject and serves the court with a red heart is Wenlong alone. That Your Majesty should uphold Heaven and punish the traitor, and hold up the bonds of order, is the right law. Yet let it also be considered that they have always been called respectful and obedient and are quite unlike the other outer peoples. Send again upright and trustworthy ministers to meet with Wenlong, gather the ministers and people openly, and ask them again and again. When the sifting is clear, we shall ask for the sage decision once more." This was reported as allowed. In the twelfth month the Ministry of Rites said again: "Your servants earlier joined the Ministry of War in sending a communication to the governor of Denglai and a dispatch to commander Mao, to send officers to investigate. Now we have received twelve sworn statements sent up from that country, and from the royal kinsmen down to the ministers and people of the eight provinces all call Jong respectful and obedient. Their vassal ministers, too, lead one another in crying out in grief, saying that at such a moment of danger there must be a lord for the country. It is right first to send down a rescript of instruction ordering Jong to take charge of the affairs of state, and at the same time to have him send out troops and gather provisions, and with Wenlong set ambushes and put out surprise forces. When order begins to come by degrees, only then send a high minister to set the rites of investiture right. In that way, in cherishing the small we shall not lose the way of making our borders firm." This was followed. In the fourth month of the fourth year Jong was invested as king of the country.

2The revolt of Yi Gwal and the displaced people

五年十二月,文龍報:「朝鮮逆黨李适、韓明璉等起兵昌城,直趨王京,被臣擒獲。餘孽韓潤、鄭梅等竄入建州,有左議府尹義立約為內應,期今冬大舉犯朝鮮。臣已咨國王防守,暫移鐵山之眾就雲從島柴薪。」登萊巡撫武之望奏:「毛帥自五月以來,營室於須彌,所謂雲從島是也。今十月又徙兵民商賈以實之,而鐵山之地空矣。故朝鮮各道疑其有逼處之嫌,甚至布兵以防禦之。今鎮臣所稱李适等之叛,尹義立之內應,臣等微聞之,而未敢遽信焉。信之則益重鮮人之疑,不信則恐貽後來之患。」兵部言:「牽制敵國者,朝鮮也;聯屬朝鮮者,毛鎮也;駕馭毛鎮者,登撫也。今撫臣與鎮臣不和,以至鎮臣與屬國不和,大不利。」帝乃飭勉鎮撫同心,而韓潤、尹義立等令朝鮮自處。倧又請撤遼民安插中土,兵部言:「遼人去留,文龍是視。文龍一日不去,則遼人一日不離。鮮人驅之入島可也,驅之離島不可也。宜令鎮臣將遼民盡刷過島,登撫刻期運糧朝鮮,量行救振,以資屯牧。」帝是之。

In the twelfth month of the fifth year Wenlong reported: "Yi Gwal, Han Myeong-ryeon and other traitors of Joseon raised troops at Changseong and drove straight for the royal capital, and were taken by your servant. The remnants, Han Yun, Jeong Mae and others, fled into Jianzhou, and Yun Ui-rip of the left council promised to answer them from within, setting this winter for a great invasion of Joseon. Your servant has already sent word to the king to guard against it, and has moved the host at Cheolsan for the time being to Unjong Island for firewood and fuel." Wu Zhiwang, governor of Denglai, memorialized: "Commander Mao has since the fifth month been building quarters at Sumi, which is the place called Unjong Island. Now in the tenth month he has moved soldiers, people and traders over to fill it, and the land of Cheolsan is empty. So the several provinces of Joseon suspect him of crowding close upon them, and have gone so far as to spread troops to keep him off. The revolt of Yi Gwal and the rest, and the inward answering of Yun Ui-rip, which the commander speaks of, your servants too have faintly heard, but we dare not believe it at once. To believe it would only make the suspicion of the Joseon people heavier. Not to believe it, we fear, would leave a trouble for later." The Ministry of War said, "What holds the enemy state in check is Joseon. What links Joseon to us is the garrison of Mao. What guides the garrison of Mao is the governor of Denglai. Now the governor and the commander are at odds, so that the commander has come to be at odds with the vassal state. This is greatly against our interest." The emperor then charged the commander and the governor to be of one mind, and left Han Yun, Yun Ui-rip and the rest for Joseon to deal with itself. Jong also asked that the people of Liaodong be gathered up and settled in the central land. The Ministry of War said, "The going or staying of the people of Liao rests with Wenlong. So long as Wenlong does not leave for a single day, the people of Liao will not leave for a single day. The people of Joseon may drive them onto the islands, but they cannot drive them off the islands. The commander should be ordered to comb out all the people of Liao and move them to the islands, and the governor of Denglai should set a term for shipping grain to Joseon and give relief in measure, to provide the means for farming and grazing." The emperor held this to be right.

3The memorial of Injo

六年十月,倧上疏曰:

In the tenth month of the sixth year Jong sent up a memorial.

4Yi Gwal and Han Myeong-ryeon

:皇朝之於小邦,覆幬之恩,視同服內。頃遭昏亂,潛通敵國,皇天震怒,降黜厥命。臣自權署之初,不敢遑寧,即命陪臣張晚為帥,李适副之,付以國中精銳,進屯寧邊,一聽毛鎮節制,以候協剿之期。而适重兵在握,潛蓄覬覦,遂與龜城府使明璉舉兵內叛,直犯京城。晚收餘兵躡其後,與京輔官兵表裏夾攻,賊皆授首,而西邊軍實及列鎮儲偫罄於是役矣。

"The favor with which the imperial court has covered and sheltered this small country has been as though we were within its own borders. Not long ago the country fell to a dark and disordered ruler, who secretly dealt with the enemy state; and august Heaven was moved to anger and sent down the stripping away of his mandate. From the first days when I took charge of the state in trust I did not dare to sit at ease. At once I named the vassal minister Jang Man commander in chief with Yi Gwal as his second, gave over to them the picked troops of the country, had them advance and encamp at Yeongbyeon, and follow the orders of the garrison of Mao in everything while awaiting the day for a joint attack. But Gwal, with heavy forces in his grasp, secretly nursed a covetous design, and at last, with Myeong-ryeon, prefect of Guseong, raised troops in revolt within and drove straight against the capital. Man gathered the remaining troops and followed close behind them, and together with the government troops around the capital caught them front and back and attacked, and the rebels all gave up their heads. Yet the war stores of the western border and the stockpiles of the several garrisons were spent to the last in this fighting.

5The provisions of Mao Wenlong

:毛鎮當全遼淪沒之後,孤軍東渡,寄寓海上,招集遼民前後數十萬,亦小邦所仰藉也。顧以封疆多故,土瘠民貧,內供本國之軍需,外濟鎮兵之待哺,生穀有限,支給實難。遼民迫於饑餒,散布村落,強者攫奪,弱者丐乞。小邦兵民被撓不堪,拋棄鄉邑,轉徙內地。遼民逐食,亦隨而入。自昌、義以南,安、肅以北,客居六七,主居三四。向者將此情形具奏,見兵部題覆處分已定,何敢再干。

The garrison of Mao, after the whole of Liao had sunk away, crossed east with a lone army and lodged upon the sea, gathering the people of Liao, several hundred thousand of them first and last, and this too is something the small country looks to and leans upon. Yet with troubles many on our borders, the soil poor and the people needy, we supply the military needs of our own country within and help feed the garrison troops without. What grain grows has its limit, and the issuing of it is truly hard. The people of Liao, driven by hunger, scatter through the villages, the strong seizing and the weak begging. The soldiers and people of the small country cannot bear the harrying, and abandon their home towns and move into the interior, while the people of Liao follow their food and come in after them. From Changseong and Uiju southward and from Anju and Sukcheon northward, six or seven in ten are newcomers and three or four are the native folk. Some time ago I set out this state of things in full, and I see that the Ministry of War has reported back and the disposition is already settled. How should I dare to trespass on it again.

6A defense of Han Yun and Yun Ui-rip

:至韓潤及弟潭係逆賊明璉子姪,亡命潛逃,因而勾引來寇。賊既叛國而去,制命已不在臣。尹義立曾任判書,本非議政。頃年差為毛鎮接伴官,不稱任使,褫職歸家,並無怨叛之事。毛鎮據王仲保等所訴,都無實事。意必有讒邪之臣,欺妄督撫,以售其交搆之計者。

As for Han Yun and his younger brother Dam, they are son and nephew of the traitor Myeong-ryeon, and fled and hid themselves, and from there drew in others and came raiding. Since the rebels had already turned against the country and gone, the command over them no longer rests with me. Yun Ui-rip once served as a minister of one of the ministries and was never of the State Council. In a past year he was appointed escort officer to the garrison of Mao, and being unequal to the charge was stripped of office and went home, and there was no matter of resentment or revolt. The garrison of Mao relied on what Wang Zhongbao and others complained of, and there is no substance in it at all. I think there must be some slanderous and crooked minister who has deceived the supreme commander and the governor and is selling his scheme to set us against each other.

Interlinear notes 1

至韓潤及弟潭係逆賊明璉子姪弟潭,明史稿傳一九四朝鮮傳、熹宗實錄卷七二天啟六年十月辛酉條俱作「弟澤」。

In "Han Yun and his younger brother Dam are son and nephew of the traitor Myeong-ryeon," the younger brother Dam (潭) is written in both the account of Joseon in the Ming shi gao and the entry for the sinyu day of the tenth month of the sixth year of Tianqi in the Xizong shilu as the younger brother Taek (澤).

7The good faith between us and Mao Wenlong

:毛帥久鎮海外,臣與周旋已近十稔。雖餼牽將竭,彼此俱困,而情誼之殷,實無少損。且其須彌之遷,直為保護累重,將以就便芻薪。一進一退,兵家常事。訛言噂沓,本不介意。竊見部撫移咨曰「虞其逼處」,曰「驅其民,驅其帥」,甚至有「布兵以防,屬國攜貳」之語,似海外情事,未盡諒悉。臣之請刷遼民,因力不足濟,初非慮及逼處也。臣方與毛鎮同心一力,建功報主,豈敢有一毫猜防意乎。

Commander Mao has long held his garrison beyond the sea, and I have gone about with him for nearly ten years. Though the food has run dry and both sides are hard pressed alike, the warmth of our good faith has truly not lessened in the least. And his move to Sumi was only to protect the heavy baggage and to go where firewood is near. To advance once and fall back once is the common business of soldiers. Though false talk buzzed thick, I paid it no mind. But I have seen in the communications of the ministry and the governor such words as 'we fear he crowds close upon them,' and 'they drive off his people, they drive off his commander,' and even 'they spread troops to keep him off, the vassal state is of two minds.' It would seem the state of things beyond the sea is not yet fully understood. My asking that the people of Liao be combed out and sent over came of my strength not being enough to save them, and was not at all out of any thought that they crowd close upon us. I am at this moment of one mind and one strength with the garrison of Mao, to build merit and repay my lord. How should I dare hold so much as a hair's breadth of a suspicious or guarded thought?"

8The emperor's answer

帝報曰:「王和協東鎮,愛戴中朝,忠貞之忱,溢乎言表。鎮軍久懸,鮮、遼雜處。久客累主,生寡食多。微王言,朕有不坐照萬里之外者。然毛帥在中朝為牽制之師,在王國則唇齒之形也。海上芻輓,已令該部區畫,刻期運濟。逃難邊民,亦令毛帥悉心計處,俾無重為王累。傳訛之言,未足介懷,幷力一心,王其勉之。」

The emperor replied: "The king is in accord with the eastern garrison and holds the central court in love and reverence, and the sincerity of his loyalty and constancy runs over beyond his words. The garrison army has long hung there, and the people of Joseon and of Liao live mixed together. The guest stays long and the host is worn, what is born is little and the eaters are many. Without the king's words I would have failed to see clearly, sitting here, what lies ten thousand li away. Yet commander Mao is to the central court an army that holds the enemy in check, and to the king's country he is as the lips to the teeth. As for the hauling of fodder over the sea, I have already ordered the ministry concerned to plan it out and set a term for shipping supplies. As for the border people who have fled the troubles, I have also ordered commander Mao to give his whole mind to dealing with them, so that they are not a burden to the king a second time. Words falsely passed along are not worth taking to heart. Join your strength and make your minds one, and let the king apply himself."

9The Jeongmyo invasion

七年三月,兵部上文龍揭言:「麗官、麗人招敵攻鐵山,傷我兵千人,殺麗兵六萬,焚糧百餘萬,敵遂移兵攻麗矣。」帝敕文龍速相機應援。登撫李嵩奏:「朝鮮叛臣韓潤等引敵入安州,節度使南以興自焚死,中國援兵都司王三桂等俱陣亡。」既復奏:「義州及郭山、凌漢、山城俱破,平壤、黃州不戰自潰,敵兵直抵中和,遊騎出入黃、鳳之間,又分向雲從,攻掠毛帥,國王及士民遷於江華以避難。」時大清兵所至輒下,朝鮮列城望風奔潰,乃遣使諭倧。倧輸款,遂班師。九月,倧奏被兵情形。時熹宗崩,莊烈帝嗣位,優詔勵勉焉。

In the third month of the seventh year the Ministry of War sent up a dispatch from Wenlong: "The officials and people of Goryeo called in the enemy to attack Cheolsan. A thousand of our soldiers were hurt, sixty thousand Goryeo soldiers were killed, more than a million measures of grain were burned, and the enemy have now moved their troops to attack Goryeo." The emperor charged Wenlong to watch for his chance and go to their support. Li Song, governor of Denglai, memorialized: "Han Yun and the other rebellious ministers of Joseon led the enemy into Anju. The military commissioner Nam I-heung burned himself to death, and Wang Sangui, regional military commissioner of the Chinese relief force, and the rest all fell in battle." Then he memorialized again: "Uiju and Gwaksan and the fortress of Neunghan are all broken, Pyongyang and Hwangju collapsed of themselves without a fight, and the enemy troops have come straight to Junghwa. Their roving horse go in and out between Hwangju and Bongsan, and a part has turned toward Unjong to attack and plunder commander Mao. The king and his gentry and people have moved to Ganghwa to escape the trouble." At that time the troops of the Great Qing brought down every place they came to, and the walled towns of Joseon broke and fled at the mere sight of them. So an envoy was sent to instruct Jong, and Jong offered his submission, and the army was then brought home. In the ninth month Jong memorialized on the state of the country after the fighting. At that time Xizong had died and the Zhuanglie emperor had come to the throne, and he encouraged Jong with a generous edict.

Interlinear notes 1

中國援兵都司王三桂等俱陣亡王三桂,熹宗實錄卷七七天啟七年三月戊寅條作「王三貴」。

In "Wang Sangui, regional military commissioner of the Chinese relief force, and the rest all fell in battle," Wang Sangui (王三桂) is written in the entry for the muin day of the third month of the seventh year of Tianqi in the Xizong shilu as Wang Sangui (王三貴).

10An attempt to change back the tribute road

崇禎二年,改每歲兩貢為一貢。先是,遼路阻絕,貢使取道登、萊,已十餘年矣。自袁崇煥督師,題改覺華,迂途冒險,其國屢請復故。至是遣戶曹判書鄭斗源從登海來,移書登撫孫元化,屬其陳請。元化委官伴送,仍疏聞。帝以水路既有成命,改途嫌於自便,不許。是年六月,督師袁崇煥殺平遼將軍左都督毛文龍於雙島。

In the second year of Chongzhen the two tribute missions a year were changed to one. Before this, the road through Liaodong was blocked, and the tribute envoys had taken their road by Dengzhou and Laizhou for more than ten years already. After Yuan Chonghuan became supreme commander he proposed changing it to Juehua, and as the way went round about and ran into danger, that country asked again and again to have the old road back. Now they sent Jeong Du-won, minister of Revenue, who came by the sea to Dengzhou and sent a letter to Sun Yuanhua, governor of Denglai, entrusting him with setting out the request. Yuanhua had an officer see him off and duly reported it by memorial. The emperor held that since there was a settled order for the sea road, changing the way came near to suiting their own convenience, and did not allow it. In the sixth month of that year the supreme commander Yuan Chonghuan killed Mao Wenlong, general who pacified Liao and left chief military commissioner, at Shuangdao.

11The submission of Kong Youde

六年六月,倧遺書總兵黃龍言:「文龍舊將孔有德、耿仲明率士卒二萬投順大清,向朝鮮徵糧。本國以有德等曩在皮島為本國患,故未之應。」龍以聞。

In the sixth month of the sixth year Jong sent a letter to the regional commander Huang Long, saying, "Kong Youde and Geng Zhongming, old commanders of Wenlong, have led twenty thousand soldiers over in submission to the Great Qing, and have demanded grain from Joseon. This country, because Youde and the rest were in past days a trouble to it while they were on Pido, has not answered them." Long reported it.

12The Byeongja invasion and the end of the Ming

十年正月,太宗文皇帝親征朝鮮,責其渝盟助明之罪,列城悉潰。朝鮮告急,命總兵陳洪範調各鎮舟師赴援。三月,洪範奏官兵出海。越數日,山東巡撫顏繼祖奏屬國失守,江華已破,世子被擒,國王出降。今大治舟艦,來攻皮島、鐵山,其鋒甚銳。宜急敕沈世魁、陳洪範二鎮臣,以堅守皮島為第一義。帝以繼祖不能協圖匡救,切責之。亡何,皮島並為大清兵所破,朝鮮遂絕,不數載而明亦亡矣。

In the first month of the tenth year Emperor Taizong Wen led a campaign against Joseon in person, calling it to account for breaking the covenant and helping the Ming, and the walled towns all collapsed. Joseon reported the emergency, and the regional commander Chen Hongfan was ordered to muster the fleets of the several garrisons and hurry to its aid. In the third month Hongfan memorialized that the officers and men had put to sea. A few days later Yan Jizu, governor of Shandong, memorialized that the vassal state had lost its hold, that Ganghwa was already broken, the crown prince taken and the king come out and surrendered, and that they were now fitting out ships and warships on a great scale and coming to attack Pido and Cheolsan, and their edge was very keen. He asked that a rescript go at once to Shen Shikui and Chen Hongfan, the two regional commanders, making the firm holding of Pido their first duty. The emperor held that Jizu had failed to plan with the others and set matters right and save them, and reproved him sharply. Before long Pido too was broken by the troops of the Great Qing, and Joseon was thereupon cut off, and in not many years the Ming also fell.

13Closing words

朝鮮在明雖稱屬國,而無異域內。故朝貢絡繹,錫賚便蕃,殆不勝書,止著其有關治亂者於篇。至國之風土物產,則具載前史,茲不復錄。

Joseon was called a vassal state under the Ming, yet it was no different from within the borders. So its tribute missions came one after another and the gifts bestowed on it were frequent, more than could well be written down. Only what bears on order and disorder has been set out in this chapter. As for the country's land and climate and its products, these are fully recorded in the earlier histories and are not set down again here.