Yetgeul › Jingbirok (A Record of Rebuke and Admonition) › Book 4 — The Geunpok Collection

Urging Kim Eung-seo and Go Eon-baek to Work as One責勵金應瑞高彥伯協心成事。啓

Jingbirok (A Record of Rebuke and Admonition) 懲毖錄 · Ryu Seong-ryong · 1633 (printed; written after the Imjin War) · 1 passages · 486 Chinese characters · reading time 4 min

Jingbirok (A Record of Rebuke and Admonition) Book 4 — The Geunpok Collection A record left by Ryu Seong-ryong, Chief State Councillor, of what he saw with his own eyes after the Imjin War ended. Its title comes from the line, "I rebuke what is past, and take heed against troubles to come." He set down without excuse how the war began and what the court failed to do. His recommendation of Yi Sun-sin, the wrangling with the Ming army, and the suffering the people endured are all recorded as they were.

近日國事方急而各處諸將不以誓心討賊爲重因爭少嫌頗有不睦之漸累形於狀啓之中尋常恠歎伏見徐渻所。啓別錄則高彥伯金應瑞等當初惹起爭端不過因坐次高下而然誠不滿一哂彥伯應瑞等効力於行陣之間皆有功勞國家之所同倚仗今則因前日。下諭已爲釋然相驩似無可慮但徐渻所論坐次事則。朝廷所當處置以止後日之爭端也我朝京外官相會坐次自有大典所宜遵行不可以他議有所移易高下於其間也法典內凡官會坐一從品秩而節度使防禦使同是奉。命使臣高彥伯旣爲嘉義金應瑞爲嘉善則會坐次序甚爲分明豈可以節度使爲藩臣視同守令而以嘉義下於嘉善哉此爭端之所由起也至於洪季男爲永川郡守鄧希玄爲義城縣令皆兼助防將本職兼職皆下於兵水使無相抗之理都元帥以季男希玄爲自己衛將使之與兵使防禦使抗禮通關此則尤無所據豈有舍官職尊卑之序而從一時軍中分部之令與專閫之臣列爲等夷哉此其處置號令之間未能合宜而致令人心不服無事而生事者也大抵輯和諸將鎭定裁抑消其忿爭之氣而使之同心勠力以濟王事者乃是元帥之任昔者楊儀魏延交爭而孔明爲元帥則終身不敢有乖戾之色各盡其才以立戰功良由處置之得宜也以此意下書于權慄及徐渻處使之遵奉施行其在各陣諸將亦一體曉論激以忠義期於協心成事何如

The affairs of the state are now urgent, yet the various commanders in place after place do not hold it weighty to pledge their hearts to striking the enemy, but quarrel over petty grievances, so that there are signs of no small discord, revealed again and again in their dispatches. This is always strange and lamentable.

Looking with respect at the separate record submitted by Seo Seong (徐渻), what first stirred up the quarrel between Go Eon-baek (高彥伯) and Kim Eung-seo (金應瑞) and the rest was nothing more than the high or low place of their seats, which is truly not worth even a single laugh. Go Eon-baek and Kim Eung-seo and the rest have exerted themselves in the camps and all have merit; they are men on whom the state alike relies. Now, by the royal admonition (下諭) of the other day, the matter has already been cleared away and they are glad with one another, so there would seem to be nothing to worry about.

Only the matter of the seating that Seo Seong discussed ought to be settled by the court, so as to stop quarrels in days to come. In our court the order of seating when officials of the capital and of the provinces meet together is laid down in the Gyeongguk daejeon (經國大典), and that is what should be followed; it cannot be shifted higher or lower by some other argument. The Gyeongguk daejeon says that whenever officials sit together they follow their ranks without exception, and the Provincial Military Commander (節度使) and the Defense Commander (防禦使) are alike envoys bearing the royal command. Go Eon-baek is already a Grand Master of Excellent Rightness (嘉義大夫) and Kim Eung-seo a Grand Master of Excellent Goodness (嘉善大夫), so the order of their sitting together is perfectly clear. How can the Provincial Military Commander be called a vassal of the border (藩臣) and looked upon as a magistrate, and a Grand Master of Excellent Rightness be placed below a Grand Master of Excellent Goodness? This is why the quarrel arose.

Hong Gye-nam (洪季男) is Magistrate of Yeongcheon and Deung Hui-hyeon (鄧希玄) is Magistrate of Uiseong, and both hold the concurrent post of Assistant Defense General (助防將); but their regular and their concurrent posts are all below the Army and Navy Commanders, so there is no ground for them to stand as equals. Yet the Supreme Field Marshal has made Hong Gye-nam and Deung Hui-hyeon his own Guard Generals (衛將) and let them exchange official documents with the Army Commander and the Defense Commander on equal terms, and for this there is even less ground. How can one cast aside the order of high and low in office and follow an order that for a time divided up the sections within the army, setting them out in the same rank as a minister entrusted with a whole region? Here the handling and the issuing of commands have not met what is fitting; they have made men's hearts unwilling to submit and have raised trouble where there was none.

It is the Field Marshal's own charge to bring the various commanders into harmony, to settle and restrain them, to dissolve their angry and quarrelsome spirit, and to make them of one mind and joined in strength so as to accomplish the king's work (王事). Long ago Yang Yi (楊儀) and Wei Yan (魏延) contended with one another, but because Kongming (孔明) was Field Marshal, to the end of their lives they did not dare show a crossed face, and each gave his talent to the full and won merit in battle, truly because the handling of them was fitting.

Would it not be well to send down a letter in this sense to Gwon Yul (權慄) and Seo Seong, that they may follow and carry it out, and likewise to admonish the various commanders in each camp alike, spurring them with loyalty and righteousness, so that they are held to joining their hearts and accomplishing the work?

Interlinear notes 3

The base text has 曉論, taken as an error for 曉諭, to admonish.

Grand Master of Excellent Rightness (嘉義大夫) stands one grade above Grand Master of Excellent Goodness (嘉善大夫).

The base text has 鄧希玄. The Veritable Records give Jeong Hui-hyeon (鄭希玄) as Magistrate of Uiseong. To be settled after collating the base text. — translator